peppermint no-bake cookies

For the holiday savings article in All You magazine this month (download the free gift tags and recipe cards, learn how to craft the inexpensive holiday packagingI made my families favorite no-bake chocolate oatmeal cookies with a twist. Peppermint!

Let’s start with ingredients. You’ll need:

  • ½ cup (1 stick) butter (I often add a little less)
  • 2 cups granulated sugar
  • ½ cup milk
  •  ½ cup cocoa
  • ½ cup peanut butter (I sometimes add more!)
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract (splurge for the real extract; it’s worth it)
  • 3 cups quick-cooking oats (I sometimes add a little less depending on how much peanut butter I use)
  • soft peppermint to taste (I used six, crushed into small pieces, for the batch and I got them at Cracker Barrel)

Quick and easy steps: Mix the sugar and cocoa together and blend until the mixture is smooth. You don’t want lumps of sugar in your cookies! 

Crush your soft peppermint in a resealable bag with a rolling pin. My kids like doing this part for me! And set aside until the end.

Move the mixture to a saucepan and add milk. Stir again until you have the consistency of chocolate syrup.

The rest of this process is very fast, so make sure you have all your ingredients and greased pan ready (or wax paper if you prefer to drop them with a spoon). Add low heat and butter. Allow butter to melt slowly and then bring mixture to a rolling boil for one minute, stirring it constantly (you want it hot enough to melt the peanut butter and cook the one minute oats, but not so hot that it burns).

Add vanilla and add peanut butter. Whip it quickly so that it melts completely.

Stir first two cups of oats in and mix well. Add third cup a little at a time. (Remember: The heat of the mixture is what cooks the oats so don’t go too slowly. Plus, they set very quickly so spoon them into a dish or drop them on wax paper as soon as the oats are mixed!) Fold in or layer your peppermint. And I like to sprinkle a bit on top.

Enjoy! And as always, I hope you’re inspired to craft, bake and create!

Join us on  facebookfollow us on twitter and pinterest. Participating in I Heart Naptime Sundae Scoop and Tatortots & Jello Cookie Exchange.

you may also like:

About Kim

Kim Byers, creative director & owner of The Celebration Shoppe. Her work has been featured in Parents, Better Homes and Gardens, All You, Pregnancy, iVillage, Huffington Post and many others. Kim is also a contributing writer for Kellogg's Snackpicks and Parade magazine, as well as craft contributor for JoAnn.

Leave a Comment


CommentLuv badge


  1. 3

    I love no-bake cookies and what a fun twist! I’ll have to try these out this holiday!

  2. 4

    You’re making me hungry! :)

  3. 5

    Wow, these cookies look so good. I’m going to save this recipe and make it next weekend. I can’t wait until the holidays. My kids love candy and cookies, and I’m a major fan of all things minty! It will be fun making these with them. Thanks so much for sharing :)

  4. 6
    Barbara Kinsler says:

    Oh my gosh. You don’t know how long I have been looking for this recipe. Friends and family have told me
    how but it wasn’t accurate. Thanks so much for this recipe.

  5. 8

    Thank you for any educational blog site. In which in addition may perhaps I receive that kind of info developed in this type of suitable usually means? I’ve a task that I’m right now managing upon, and i have experienced the style out there intended for such information.


  1. [...] And make sure you check out my DIY punch design holiday gift bag idea (all for under $.40 per package and super cute if I do say so) and peppermint no-bake cookie recipe and pictorial! [...]

  2. [...] Today I’m sharing my craft for the article. I wanted to share an idea that would be adorable, easy and of course, inexpensive. I personally like to give little “happy” gifts to my sons’ teachers, our neighbors, and a number of others who make an impact in our lives throughout the year, but it can get pricey. So I bake! This year I’m going to make our favorite, no-bake chocolate oatmeal cookies (so yummy when warm) and I’ve added a peppermint twist. [...]